The top 23 Justice Society member selector results of 450 participants. Percentages indicate the frequency of the self-selected participants' top results for Justice Society member selector.

#1	12.7%	Batman
#2	11.6%	Flash I
#3	10.2%	Atom
#4	9.8%	Green Lantern I
#5	8.2%	Sandman
#6	6.7%	Hourman I
#7	6.4%	Superman
#8	5.3%	Black Canary I
#9	5.3%	Mister Terrific I
#10	5.1%	Doctor Mid-Nite I
#11	4.9%	Starman I
#12	3.1%	Johnny Thunder
#13	2.0%	Hourman II
#14	1.8%	Doctor Fate
#15	1.6%	Doctor Mid-Nite II
#16	1.6%	Sand
#17	1.3%	Hawkman
#18	1.1%	Hawkgirl
#19	0.4%	Starman VI
#20	0.4%	Wildcat
#21	0.2%	Mister Terrific II
#22	0.2%	Wonder Woman
#23	0.0%	Black Canary II