The top 25 WWE/WWF Superstar Selector results of 97 participants. Percentages indicate the frequency of the self-selected participants' top results for WWE/WWF Superstar Selector.

#1	22.7%	Shawn Michaels
#2	16.5%	Rob Van Dam
#3	9.3%	Rey Mysterio Junior
#4	8.2%	Kane
#5	8.2%	Kurt Angle
#6	5.2%	Billy Gunn
#7	4.1%	Doink the Clown
#8	4.1%	Jake "The Snake" Roberts
#9	3.1%	Goldberg
#10	3.1%	Hulk Hogan
#11	3.1%	Mideon
#12	3.1%	Scott Hall
#13	3.1%	X-Pac
#14	2.1%	Chris Jericho
#15	1.0%	British Bulldog
#16	1.0%	Kevin Nash
#17	1.0%	The Rock
#18	1.0%	Undertaker
#19	0.0%	Bret Hart
#20	0.0%	Brock Lesnar
#21	0.0%	Chris Benoit
#22	0.0%	Randy Savage
#23	0.0%	Road Dogg
#24	0.0%	Vader
#25	0.0%	Viscera