The top 10 Pirates of the Caribbean: Cream of the Gold Selector results of 78 participants. Percentages indicate the frequency of the self-selected participants' top results for Pirates of the Caribbean: Cream of the Gold Selector.

#1	42.3%	Captain Jack Sparrow
#2	19.2%	Elizabeth Swann
#3	11.5%	Cotton's parrot
#4	6.4%	Anamaria
#5	6.4%	Jack, the Monkey
#6	5.1%	Governor Swann
#7	5.1%	Will Turner
#8	2.6%	Commodore Norrington
#9	1.3%	Mr. Gibbs
#10	0.0%	Captain Barbossa