The top 13 Pickleton Online Character Selector results of 25 participants. Percentages indicate the frequency of the self-selected participants' top results for Pickleton Online Character Selector.

#1	80.0%	Brittany Bopper
#2	16.0%	Heather Ardedron
#3	4.0%	Linette Peters
#4	0.0%	Annalissa Ramonni
#5	0.0%	Brian Putnam
#6	0.0%	Cassandra "C.C." Chino
#7	0.0%	Christina Van Pire
#8	0.0%	Hilel Ardedron
#9	0.0%	Lydia Ardedron
#10	0.0%	Mr. Hall (the band director)
#11	0.0%	Odessa
#12	0.0%	Tim Waechlatic
#13	0.0%	Zoe Igasu