The top 25 Mario Character Selector results of 226 participants. Percentages indicate the frequency of the self-selected participants' top results for Mario Character Selector.

#1	26.1%	Any of the Koopalings (Larry, Lemmy, Iggy, Wendy, Morton, Roy, Ludwig)
#2	14.6%	Princess Peach Toadstool
#3	8.8%	Mario Mario
#4	8.4%	Princess Daisy Sarasa
#5	8.0%	Birdo
#6	6.6%	Pauline
#7	4.0%	Toad
#8	3.1%	Kammy Magikoopa
#9	2.7%	Captain Syrup
#10	2.7%	Prince Pine
#11	2.2%	Jr. Koopa
#12	1.8%	D.K. (Donkey Kong from the DKC games)
#13	1.8%	Yoshi
#14	1.3%	Boshi
#15	1.3%	Luigi Mario
#16	1.3%	Waluigi ???
#17	0.9%	Kamek Magikoopa
#18	0.9%	Stanley the Bugman
#19	0.9%	Tatanga
#20	0.4%	Boo
#21	0.4%	King Bowser Koopa
#22	0.4%	Lakitu
#23	0.4%	Mouser
#24	0.4%	Wario ???
#25	0.4%	Wart