The top 25 Country Music Superstars results of 41 participants. Percentages indicate the frequency of the self-selected participants' top results for Country Music Superstars.

#1	34.1%	Faith Hill
#2	17.1%	Bill Monroe
#3	12.2%	Brad Paisley​
#4	9.8%	Hank Williams
#5	7.3%	Dolly Parton
#6	4.9%	Johnny Cash​
#7	2.4%	Bob Wills
#8	2.4%	Carrie ​Underwood​
#9	2.4%	Elvis Presley​
#10	2.4%	George Strait​
#11	2.4%	Tammy Wynette
#12	2.4%	Willie Nelson​
#13	0.0%	Garth Brooks​
#14	0.0%	George Jones​
#15	0.0%	Hank Williams, Jr.
#16	0.0%	Jimmie Rodgers
#17	0.0%	Loretta Lynn
#18	0.0%	Merle Haggard​
#19	0.0%	Patsy Cline​
#20	0.0%	Randy Travis​
#21	0.0%	Reba McEntire​
#22	0.0%	Tim McGraw​
#23	0.0%	Toby Keith​
#24	0.0%	Vince Gill​
#25	0.0%	Waylon Jennings