Survey Says: Top American Idol! results, Television Survey Selectsmart.com The top 12 American Idol! results of 102 participants. Percentages indicate the frequency of the self-selected participants' top results for American Idol! . Rate Survey Says (5=best, 0=poor) #1 54.9% Trenyce #2 22.5% Carmen Rasmusen #3 10.8% Clay Aiken #4 4.9% Kimberly Caldwell #5 2.9% Corey Clark #6 2.9% Julia DeMato #7 1.0% Charles Grigsby #8 0.0% Josh Gracin #9 0.0% Kimberly Locke #10 0.0% Rickey Smith #11 0.0% Ruben Studdard #12 0.0% Vanessa Olivarez