The top 20 Fellowship of the Selectors results of 41 participants. Percentages indicate the frequency of the self-selected participants' top results for Fellowship of the Selectors.

#1	51.2%	Frodo Baggins
#2	17.1%	Arwen
#3	12.2%	Gandalf the Grey
#4	12.2%	Legolas Greenleaf
#5	2.4%	Boromir
#6	2.4%	Elrond Halfelven
#7	2.4%	Galadriel
#8	0.0%	Anonymous Ringwraith
#9	0.0%	Balrog of Morgoth
#10	0.0%	Bilbo Baggins
#11	0.0%	Cave-Troll
#12	0.0%	Gimli the Dwarf
#13	0.0%	Gollum (Sméagol)
#14	0.0%	Lurtz
#15	0.0%	Meriadoc Brandybuck
#16	0.0%	Peregrin Took
#17	0.0%	Samwise Gamgee
#18	0.0%	Saruman the White
#19	0.0%	Strider (Aragorn)
#20	0.0%	The Disembodied Eye of Sauron