SelectSmart.com
Before you decide
POST YOUR COMMENTS on our message board dedicated to Lorie's pages. Tell us what you think and see what others have to say. ONLY RESPECTFUL AND ON-TOPIC POSTS WILL BE RETAINED. Or, send your comments directly to the author.
Read Lorie's related page on James Twyman's purported homeless shelter in Iraq.
GO TO ALL LINKS.
|
|
|
|
September 22, 2003.A CAUTIONARY COMMENTARY TO MY COMMUNITY, ASHLAND, OREGON. (AND TO THE WORLD)
INDIGO: THE COLOR OF MONEY
Many are excited about the upcoming New Age movie, "Indigo," written, produced, and directed by three renowned individuals who now live in Ashland - James Twyman, Neale Donald Walsch, and Stephen Simon. Appealing are the career opportunities, the camaraderie of movie-making, the promoting of spirituality and messages of peace and love. Promoters say it will stimulate the local economy and help our schools. But after examining the Indigo Child movement, and specifically the activities of co-writer/producer James Twyman, I see potential consequences for the community -- and for children.
INDIGO CHILDREN
The Indigo Child concept was first popularized by the book, "The Indigo Children," written by the husband and wife team Lee Carroll and Jan Tober. Carroll also portrays himself as a channeler for "Kryon," a spiritual entity who predicted the coming of the Indigo Children - will wonders never cease?
The authors say that "the Indigo Child is a boy or girl who displays a new and unusual set of psychological attributes, revealing a pattern of behavior generally undocumented before." For example, they act like royalty, have difficulty with absolute authority unless given choices or explanations, are easily frustrated (e.g. when waiting in line), are not shy, have difficulty with guilt-based discipline, are non-conformist, may seem antisocial and prefer to be with their own kind, and may have social difficulties in school. I, for one, see nothing new, unusual, or unheard-of here.
The Indigo Child concept may appeal especially to parents of children with mental health challenges, e.g. ADD, ADHD, autism, bi-polar disorder, conduct disorder, or a difficult temperament. Proponents target these label- and medication-wary parents. So, what is the harm in giving parents a positive spin on their children for a change -- like Indigo?
Besides parents possibly foregoing beneficial, if not life-saving, treatment for children with mental or neurological disorders, some proponents of the Indigo movement infuse children with a false sense of human superiority and a bizarre paranormal identity. Mutilating science while claiming scientific proof, children are led to believe by trusted adults that they were born members of a new breed of the human race, the next step in human evolution, that their genes were somehow altered -- perhaps as a result of divine or extraterrestrial intervention, or spontaneous genetic mutation accomplished by non other than the children themselves. Some children come to believe they are endowed with extraordinary powers such as clairvoyance, clairaudience, clairsentience, healing powers, pre-birth and previous life recall, etc. Tober and Carroll tell us that Indigo Children don’t fit in and feel uncomfortable when not with other Indigos. Small wonder!
Similar to the Indigo Child model, you may hear about The New Children, The Masters, Ascending Children, Star Children, Crystal or Chrystalline Children, Metagifted Children, Millennium Children, Children of the New Dream, Children of the New Times, Children of Aids (genetically altered child beings who are purportedly immune to all disease), and Super Psychic Children. Someone even wrote online about the "evil counterparts," the "End-Times Children." (I suspect it's just a matter of time before this logical progression of the ill-conceived supernatural child postulate takes on a life of its own.) James Twyman seems to prefer the terms Children of Oz or Psychic Children; and as of 10/2003, "The Mystic Children;" and as of around 1/2006, "The New Children."
NOT JUST ABOUT PEACE AND LOVE
Twyman, and other Indigo Child proponents, may try to shift our focus to the children’s message and mission of peace and love, but Twyman, for one, readily capitalizes on his own and children's purported paranormal abilities.
Twyman sells books and Internet course based on the Psychic Children. He holds pricey Psychic Children conferences, camps, and fairs, charging about $300 for adults for the main conference. He offers an Internet course on telekinetic spoon-bending. He purportedly conversed with Jesus ("Jeshua") who revealed to Twyman through a "Divine Partnership" the "secrets of Heaven and Earth," which Twyman turned into an Internet course for required donations -- with a suggested retail value of $150.
He purports to have frequently "conversed" telepathically from abroad with a Psychic Child he calls Thomas from Bulgaria, and other Psychic Children - providing more content for books and Internet courses. A "secret society" of spiritual masters called "emissaries of light" purportedly revealed themselves in the flesh to Twyman in Bosnia (before they disbanded) -- more content for courses and books.
He doesn't always make a distinction in his writings between his purported mystical interactions and actual, in-the-flesh interactions. When confronted with suspected and admitted misrepresentations, he conveys that he would rather we focus on the truth of his messages than the truth of his experiences - and this seems to satisfy many people, but for others honesty is a prerequisite for credibility.
In response to a question posed by a New Age organization, NewHeavenNewEarth (NHNE) , for an investigative report on Twyman in 1999, Twyman wrote reassuringly: "…as I have been telling those who inquire, Emissary of Light is not an organization, and I am not a guru. I am not asking for donations, and I do not seek either fame or adoration. This is not about me. It is about peace."
Well, certainly Twyman has asked for and collected a wealth of donations (sometimes with a required minimum donation and collected using guilt-pressure) and fees. He says that his organization, The Beloved Community, is now a "registered church organization." He purchased 42 acres of property in the local area, (for which he solicited donations to buy), for psychic children retreats, to start a Emissary of Light type of monastery, and to house workshops for his new "Seminary of Spiritual Peacemaking." He recently announced a five-year goal of 50 churches worldwide. After graduating from the seminary, Twyman suggests graduates can work with the Indigo and Psychic Children.
I believe adults are responsible for deciding what to believe, but as paranormal claims are key to Twyman's growing popularity, and income, and as he targets minors around the world, I think we owe it to the Children of Oz to pull the curtain on the wizard by scrutinizing his claims.
MISLEADING REPORTS OF SCIENTIFIC PROOF
Twyman reports scientific proof of several spurious claims, including that children develop ESP at his fairs after Brain Respiration (BR) training. BR was created by Ilchi Lee, aka Seung Heun Lee, founder of Dahn Centers and many other organizations. (Lee and Walsch are also affiliated). Twyman and Lee have reported that the University of California at Irvine, specifically the Center for Aging and Dementia, has researched and "confirmed" the effects of BR. However, this department at UCI tells me they have not conducted any studies on Lee's BR program, per se -- let alone confirmed its paranormal claims.
OILY-SKINNED PSYCHIC CHILDREN
At Twyman's psychic fairs for children, kids are persuaded to believe that sticking a lightweight spoon to their forehead is a result of psychokinetic power. The fact is that everyone can stick a lightweight spoon to their forehead if they first rub the spoon on their skin, especially the forehead and chin, coating the spoon with slightly sticky sebum.
X-RAY VISION
At Twyman's psychic children's fairs, parents paid for their kids' ESP powers to be tested (charging subjects is almost unheard-of in scientific research) before and after participation in Ilchi Lee's BR training. The children were asked to identify certain shapes, colors, or simple words while blindfolded. Lee shows a video at his website of blindfolded children reading books held close to the face. But, the blindfolds were provided and the tests conducted by the program's staff. Naturally, Twyman and Lee report amazing results.
Magicians and paranormal investigators have continually exposed "x-ray vision" as flimflammery, e.g. perhaps the blindfolded person can see through a space between the blindfold and the nose, a pinhole in the blindfold, cloth that appears opaque but is translucent when held close to the face, or verbal cues are provided by testers or shills. Sometimes it’s a matter of working with probabilities. For example, when asked to pick a number between one and ten, the number seven is picked most often.
USING HANDICAPPED CHILDREN
Twyman presents severely handicapped children and young adults at his psychic children's fairs - e.g. a young woman called "Grandma Chandra," who is known for her psychic readings using an alphabet board or mental telepathy (even over the phone for a mere $100) and a six year old boy named Nicholas, who has purportedly written a book full of spiritual adult-level insights (since age three) with an alphabet board. Twyman also offers telepathically received messages from a severely handicapped boy from Japan named Koya.
Telepathic powers can easily be imagined, or fabricated, especially when the purported sender is not able or available to object. Claims of telepathic powers are not hard to test and have been discredited many times. Mental telepathy is implausible, and as such, the burden of proof (or at least of solid, credible evidence) lies with the claimant. Without compelling evidence via unbiased, carefully controlled, and replicated tests, deception or delusion is fairly assumed.
Facilitated Communication, whereby someone physically assists a handicapped person in using a communication device, has so often been shown to convey the thoughts of the facilitator (often unintentionally by hopeful parents) that this method simply cannot be trusted.
Imagine how frustrating, if not cruel, to have someone else claim that his/her own thoughts are yours while you remain helpless to protest. Telepathic and facilitated communication engenders high risk of subjugating a helpless person's true thoughts, feelings, needs, and wishes -- and high risk of defrauding a trusting audience.
SPOON-BENDING
Through Ilchi Lee's Brain Respiration training and Twyman's own Internet course, Twyman teaches psychokinetic spoon-bending. Twyman says that if you can bend a spoon mentally, you can bend the world toward peace mentally, the logic of which eludes me.
Magicians use several tricks and gimmicks to appear to mentally bend utensils, e.g. an invisible cut or weak spot in the shaft of the spoon, using previously fatigued utensils, utensils made with low melting point or "shape memory" alloys, sleight-of-hand to switch to a previously bent spoon, and distraction while secretly bending the metal, etc. - with new methods devised as old ones are suspected or exposed. Even the elusive mentalist Uri Geller, much admired by Twyman, was rendered inept on Johnny Carson's Tonight Show in the early 70's when the station exercised some controls against cheating, like using the station's props rather than those from Geller's own bag of tricks. (Watch a video clip of the show.)
Spoonbending ala Twyman's Internet course involves sheer power of suggestion -- choose a thin metal spoon to begin with, bend it manually again and again (weakening the metal), and shake it to, as Twyman says, "use the force of gravity." Psychological yes; kinetic yes, but obviously not psycho-kinetic. In week-four, readers are instructed in the same cadence to take out a $10 or $20 bill, hold it tightly, feel how it will help children connect with each other, fold the bill in a piece of paper, put it into an envelope, and send it to Twyman's organization to pay for his Psychic Children gatherings.
On his website, Twyman provides a fork-bending demonstration on video where he bends a fork without his even touching it, just by coaxing it a little bit with his finger - amazing! Amazingly deceptive, that is. Hank Lee’s Magic Factory sells online a melting fork for a costly $695. Keep those peace and love donations rolling in, folks.
PUT YOUR MOUTH WHERE THE MONEY IS -- $2.5 MILLION!
The James Randi Educational Foundation offers over a million dollars to "anyone who can show, under proper observing conditions, evidence of any paranormal, supernatural, or occult power or event." Similar organizations offer additional large sums of money, totaling about 2.5 million. I implore Twyman, Ilchi Lee, and their cohorts, or just one of the purported millions of psychic adults and children to come forward and take the scientific challenges. You owe it to children around the world, as it is the children who ultimately will pay the price if they are being deceived or used to deceive others.
If Twyman can really bend spoons with his mind, which he reports he couldn't even stop doing after he met his first Psychic Child, he can certainly pass relatively easier scientific challenges. Twyman can use the money to further his stated goals of world peace and love, to save the dolphins. Winning would create a shock-wave throughout the scientific community - as none of the few who have ventured to apply has ever proceeded beyond the preliminary test.
As the New Age movement grows from marginal to mainstream, we need programs for New Age consumer protection. We must caution educators and parents about, and object to, programs with paranormal underpinnings, like the Indigo Child and Brain Respiration, which are fervently marketed to private and public schools. We need age-appropriate critical-thinking skills programs in education, starting in the early grades. We must educate ourselves and our children on the scientific method of inquiry, how to evaluate studies and spot pseudo-science and pseudo-scientists. We must help our children to develop radar to detect and avoid deceptive New Age profiteers - no matter how noble their stated cause.
Twyman's Seminary of Spiritual Peacemaking promises:
(content added 1/30/2006)
- Ordination graduates "may continue to pursue a Masters of Divinity degree."
- "The Seminary has a religious accreditation through ACI (Accrediting
Commission International)."
- "You may continue...for a Doctorate of Divinity...through our affiliation with
the...University of Integrative Learning (UIL).
But, BUYER BEWARE:
- Some states, like Oregon, require state authorization, or an approved application for religious exemption, to operate programs offering advanced degrees. Oregon's Office of Degree Authorization says: Beloved Community Seminary: (updated 5/11/06, as TBC announced that their masters degrees are issued from their Hawaii office): "Not an Oregon degree-granting entity. Degrees issued in Oregon are not valid. Degrees issued in Hawaii are legal for use in Oregon with disclaimer.."
- In the US, "accreditation" (not to be confused with state authorization/license, a separate process), is
voluntary and is conducted by private agencies that inspect and evaluate colleges who apply. This provides
consumers with some quality assurance about a school, among other things. The US Department of Education (DOE)
and the
Council for Higher Education Accreditation
(CHEA) list approved US accrediting agencies and their accredited educational institutions.
Twyman says his seminary is accredited by ACI. ACI is not listed as recognized by the US DOE or the CHEA; thus, Oregon (and other states too?) would regard accreditation from ACI as meaningless for the purpose of state approval.
Diploma/accreditation mill expert John Bear cautioned consumers about ACI in this Quackwatch report.
From ACI's website's FAQ: "Q. Does accreditation make a school "above the law of the land"? A. No. ACI members are encouraged to work in the bounds of the laws of the country or state where they live." This apparently didn't stop ACI from "accrediting" Twyman's seminary, as it is unapproved by the state of Oregon to issue Masters degrees.
ACI's website says they have not sought recognition from the US DOE or CHEA because of separation of church and state. The fact is, ACI is not a religious organization, and the US DOE and CHEA don't address an accrediting agency's religious beliefs (nor do states) -- they address program/service quality.
ACI claims they are "the world´s largest non-government school accrediting association." In reality, all accrediting agencies in the US are non-governmental, and ACI is certainly not the largest.
A big red flag: ACI does not publish a list of schools they claim to have accredited.
- The University of Integrative Learning (UIL), to which the Beloved Community seminary offers graduates a transfer for a doctorate degree, is not accredited. Their website, AIWP.ORG, reports that they have "deliberately, intentionally and passionately not sought State accreditation." (Note: California approved their Doctor of Divinity and other religious degrees as "exempt," based as religious instruction. This is not the same thing as "accreditation.")
(3/26/06 Note: At this point, it appears that The Beloved community has removed from their emissaryoflight website most of that to which this section pertains.)
Interesting aside: I asked Dr. Briggs for his opinion on why the children would be willing to cheat, and he said maybe because "it looks like fun, and they want to please the adults and fit in with the group. There is always tremendous applause whenever a kid demonstrates HSP, a lot of candy, praise, happiness."
(Note: Although Dr. Matt Briggs and Dr. Sung W. Lee are instructors/researchers with Weill Cornell Medical College, they conducted this experiment as independents, not under the auspices of Cornell. The information I provided here about this study was reviewed for accuracy by Dr. Briggs.)
Ilchi Lee failed to demonstrate children's blind-folded vision at UCI:
Excerpt from August 7, 2005 article in NY Journal News by Shawn Cohen:
- "Pseudoscience would actually be a generous term for what they do," said Brian Cummings, a scientist at the University of
California at Irvine, where Lee gave a demonstration two years ago. "The real term should be that this is a cult or religion
of some sort."
"At the university's Institute for Brain Aging, Lee attempted to demonstrate the power of brain respiration by holding up cards and having his child "trainees" see through them and identify objects on the back side. It didn't work, Cummings said. "He was there for two reasons: One, to advertise that he was invited to give a lecture at UC Irvine so he could have an official brochure saying he went there and, second, to convince us that there's something to this brain respiration and that we should study it," he said. "It was just silly."
LINKS:
CRITICAL COMMENTARIES ON JAMES TWYMAN'S CLAIMS
BLOGS, ARTICLES, AND COMMENTARIES CRITICAL OF THE INDIGO-PSYCHIC CHILDREN MOVEMENT:
- Lorie's comment on "Little Boy Blue":
This article features a little boy, Dusk, who is reportedly "hearing thoughts" of classmates and experiencing learning difficulties at school. At one point, an Indigo Child enthusiast who hangs out a shingle to counsel children asked the boy: "Are you an Indigo?" The boy answered: "I'm an avatar; I can recognize the four elements of earth, wind, water, and fire. The next avatar won't come for 100 years." "The man seemed impressed," the reporter wrote, and the man then asked the boy to read his mind.
It did sound like an esoteric thing for a little boy to know about, until a friend of mine mentioned that he probably watches the Nichelodeon TV show, "Avatar." I didn't know about this show, so I asked my son: "Can you recognize the four elements?" He answered: "Fire, water, air, and earth; I love that show." "How often does a new avatar appear?" my friend then asked her own son. "Everyone 100 years," he answered. I had to laugh, but humor gave way to sympathy for the little boy featured in the article, as the infusing of supernatural/paranormal powers to this suggestible little boy by trusted adults, as described in this article, worsens from there.
Little Boy Blue's Mother Seeing RED
On March 15, 2006, Lorie received e-mail message(s) from Dusk's mother, subject header: "Little Boy Blue's Mother Seeing RED." Pertinent excerpts are posted here, with her permission.
Hi there,
I am Dusk Conrad's mother.
I had no idea what crazyness was going on! ... Dusk and his brother are currently in my care.
I truly appreciate the effort and information that you contribute to help people make SMART CHOICES.
How unfortunate that Dusk's father did not take the time to read your (article) or research anything before being so
willing and ready to hand his child over to the influence of strangers who may have ill intentions.
I'm in shock.
Thank you,
Later, Cat also clarified: "The truth is, they [her two sons] never
had "behavioral" problems here with me, or in school. Excellent grades. We have structure in our household."
And: "I would like Dusk's situation to show that kids can easily be "misdiagnosed" with behavioral problems and parent's
(with the help of Indigo supporters) can "misdiagnose" (their) kids as having supernatural powers just from the child
repeating cool stuff he saw on his cartoon shows. Hmmm."
Cat Robertson
DISCUSSION FORUMS/BOARDS WITH (some or mostly) CRITICAL COMMENTARIES:
Note from Lorie: As Indigo child proponents convey that Indigo kids feel and act like royalty, have difficulty with authority, are impatient, and are "system busters" who don't respond to discipline, some Internet rants have emerged calling kids/teens who identify with this movement "spoiled brats" who just need a spanking, or worse. While I share their indignance over attributing superiority (a new breed of human, an evolutionary jump in human consciousness, etc.) to children displaying arrogant and fractious behavior, I want my readers to know that I am uncomfortable with that kind of response directed at individuals (and I do believe that most are responding to the concept and not to individuals). The Indigo Child movement attracts parents of children with AD/HD and other neurological disorders that often cause conduct problems. The last thing these challenged kids need is a call for corporal punishment or to be called names.
BENDING THE TRUTH WITH SPOONS AND FORKS (and sticking it to them):
POSSIBLE RATIONAL EXPLANATIONS BEHIND MISPERCEPTIONS OF "NEW," PSYCHIC CHILDREN:
FACILITATED COMMUNICATION:
ILLUMINATING THE HYPE ABOUT AURAS:
PARANORMAL PROPONENTS JOURNEY TO SKEPTICISM:
REVIEWS ON THE MOVIE, INDIGO, THAT YOU WON'T FIND ON JAMES TWYMAN'S WEBSITE
OTHER RELATED:
OTHER COMMENTARIES BY LORIE ANDERSON
DISCLAIMER OF LIABILITY: Neither this Web page's author, nor SelectSmart.com, makes any warranty, express or implied,
including warranties of merchantability and fitness for a particular purpose, or assumes any legal liability for the
accuracy, completeness, legitimacy, or usefulness of any product, service, or information presented by outside Web sites
pointed to or hypertext linked on this Web site.
2003-2005 Lorie Anderson SelectSmart.com All Rights Reserved.
NON-PSYCHOTIC HALLUCINATIONS AND VISIONS
SYNAESTHESIA:
CONCERNS ABOUT BLUE-GREEN ALGAE (a product recommended by some Indigo Child proponents):
DISCLAIMER OF ENDORSEMENT: Any reference obtained via this Web page to a specific commercial or non-commercial product,
process, or service does not constitute or imply an endorsement, recommendation, or favoring by this Web page's author or
SelectSmart.com of the product, process, or service, or its producer or provider. The views and opinions expressed in any
referenced document or any Web site linked to this Web page do not necessarily state or reflect those of this Web page's
author or SelectSmart.com.
(Please do not copy this or any of of Lorie's pages,
other than excerpts, without Lorie's written permission. Feel free to link to this page.)
SelectSmart.com
FastCounter by bCentral