Survey Says: Top Jelly Belly Flavor Selector results, Food & Beverages Survey Selectsmart.com The top 8 Jelly Belly Flavor Selector results of 15755 participants. Percentages indicate the frequency of the self-selected participants' top results for Jelly Belly Flavor Selector. #1 35.3% Cinnamon #2 26.6% Green Apple #3 16.3% Tangerine #4 6.5% Island Punch #5 5.6% Licorice #6 5.3% Piña Colada #7 2.6% Tutti Frutti #8 1.8% Coconut Privacy statement. © 1999 - 2024 Selectsmart®.com Do not copy without written permission. All Rights Reserved. SelectSmart® is a registered trademark.